Book of the Month, July 2025 – The Unpleasantness at The Bellona Club by Dorothy L Sayers

Audiobook cover showing retired General Fentiman apparently asleep at his club

For July’s Book of the Month I have chosen The Unpleasantness at The Bellona Club by Dorothy L Sayers (originally published in 1928). Sayers has long been considered one of the Queens of Crime from the golden era between the two World Wars, along with Agatha Christie, Margery Allingham and Ngaio Marsh.

This novel was the fourth excursion in print for the amateur detective Lord Peter Wimsey, who solves the riddle of the all too convenient death of 90-year-old General Fentiman after his body is found in the library of the Bellona Club following the two minutes silence on Remembrance Day. Part of the inspiration for the story is probably the old joke about an Englishman’s club being so stuffy it was hard to tell the living members from the dead.

The plot is slick and skilful, with vivid characterisations that linger in the memory afterwards. While much of the action is based in upper-class circles remote from the experiences of most present-day readers, it does also include some haunting background descriptions of life for others between the wars. Particularly striking were references to the effects of shell shock, a form of PTSD which Wimsey had managed to overcome after the war but which was still extremely debilitating for another character, Captain George Fentiman.

The version of the novel I bought was an audiobook recording. The BBC had broadcast the story as a full-cast radio drama in 1975 and later released the recording on cassettes in 1998 and CDs in 2006. I use such recordings to help me get to sleep at night when my mind is restless, and this fitted the bill. The story contains plenty of detail to engage the errant brain on the borders of sleep, without including the sometimes gruesome detail found in more modern crime dramas. The novel was also well-enough structured to show no obvious plot holes even after repeated replaying.

So there we have it, July’s Book of the Month! Be sure to check back in August when I’ll be revealing another must read.

Maggie x

Scroll to Top